Orange Blossom Award - The Beacon: Erica Sutherlin

by Avery Anderson
On the final day of 2025 and the end of our first annual Orange Blossom Awards. The Beacon Award honors one person this year who didn’t just show up—but pushed the field forward. Who expanded what felt possible. Who said yes when it would’ve been easier to say “not my job,” and kept showing up long after the applause faded.
This is someone whose impact isn’t loud—but it’s unmistakable.
You see it in the doors they open.
The people they lift.
The momentum that exists because they were there.
This year’s Beacon Award goes to Erica Sutherlin—a leader nominated by multiple people, for the same reason: she shows up. Every day. With intention, care, and an almost radical sense of joy about what the arts can be when they’re built with people in mind.
As artistic executive director of Studio@620, Sutherlin isn’t simply programming seasons. She’s widening the field—who gets to make work, who gets paid to learn, and who gets invited into the room.

Why this year mattered
In 2025, Sutherlin directed Cadillac Crew to a sold-out run while launching a new co-production model with Powerstories—a tangible example of collaboration over competition. The production didn’t just fill seats; it built capacity, creating first-time leadership opportunities backstage and new pathways for artists to grow.
She moved forward a new theatre program in partnership with University of South Florida St. Petersburg, strengthening the pipeline between education and professional practice. She continued a commitment to resident companies like projectALCHEMY, while opening the door to new ones like Dead Canary Theatre—giving organizations not just space, but room to grow.
And her impact radiates outward. From WUSF to Foundation for a Healthy St. Petersburg, from Tampa Bay Arts Passport to Pinellas Diaspora Arts Project, Sutherlin shows up for the ecosystem—not just her own stage.
The work behind the glow
In a recent profile with Creative Loafing Tampa Bay, Sutherlin outlined a three-phase rollout at the Studio: opening the doors wider, building sustainable revenue beyond any one leader, and reshaping the organization’s identity so The Studio—its people, its purpose—takes center stage.
She’s candid about the math. Producing a show costs roughly $35,000. Tickets cover only a fraction. Sustainability, she argues, comes from valuing artists’ labor and building partnerships that keep the doors open—not just today, but long after any single season closes.
“The space is full and vibrating,” Sutherlin said, “but we are still trying to keep our doors open… If we talk about how much we love the Studio and how it’s been a beacon, we need to support it.”
How the ripples become waves
What makes Erica’s work matter isn’t any single production or partnership—it’s the pattern.
When she says yes to a co-production, she’s modeling collaboration in a field trained to compete. When she hires someone into their first leadership role, she’s changing who feels qualified to lead next time. When she opens the doors to a new resident company, she’s stabilizing artists who would otherwise be scrambling—giving them time, space, and trust to grow real roots here.
Those decisions don’t stay contained within one building.
They move outward—into other organizations that borrow the model, into artists who carry those expectations with them, into audiences who start to recognize the Studio not just as a venue, but as a civic space. A place where learning is paid, risk is supported, and community isn’t a buzzword—it’s a practice.
This is how ecosystems actually change: not through grand gestures, but through consistent leadership that aligns values with action. Over and over again.
That’s why Sutherlin’s name came up again—and again—when nominations opened. And it’s why the Beacon this year isn’t only about what she’s built so far, but about what’s now possible because she’s here.
As Clareann Despain, artistic director of Powerstories, put it: “Erica is a cultural force. Her vision and artistry is unparalleled. She is a leader in every sense of the word.”
Some people reflect light.
Others make sure it keeps spreading.
That’s the Beacon.
What are the Orange Blossom Award
A month-long series from The Arts Passport celebrating the people and organizations whose quiet, steady work strengthens Tampa Bay’s arts ecosystem. No applications. No campaigning. Just community-driven recognition, released daily in December.
Other Orange Blossom Stories:
December 1
by Avery Anderson Every arts community has its stars — the people onstage, the names in the program, the ones audiences come to see. But Tampa Bay’s arts ecosystem runs on something deeper: the quiet, unglamorous, fiercely devoted labor of people who rarely get recognized. That’s why The Arts
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 2
by Avery Anderson Today’s Orange Blossom Award goes not to an individual, but to an unlikely coalition — four Tampa Bay theaters that came together this fall to help a much smaller organization make a very public case for its future. Dunedin Public Theater is barely two years old — volunteer-run,
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 3
by Avery Anderson Today’s Orange Blossom Award goes to someone whose work rarely draws attention, yet hundreds of St. Pete readers feel its ripple effects every single month — whether they realize it or not. Before most book clubs at Tombolo Books ever meet, before the emails go out or
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 4
by Avery Anderson Today’s Orange Blossom Award goes to someone whose work is so woven into Tampa’s arts landscape that many people don’t realize they’ve been shaped by it — not directly, but through the countless stories she’s helped bring into the world. Long before a
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 5
by Avery Anderson Every day in December, The Arts Passport is recognizing someone whose quiet, persistent work holds this region’s arts scene together — the kind of people who rarely get applause but absolutely deserve it. We call them the Orange Blossom Awards: small spotlights for the folks who keep
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 6
by Avery Anderson In nearly every corner of Tampa Bay theatre, from splashy musicals to the smallest black box, there’s one person quietly shaping how audiences see the work — long after the curtain falls. He’s not onstage. He’s not giving notes. He’s usually somewhere in the
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 7
by Avery Anderson A quick reminder of what the Orange Blossom Awards are — in a city full of shiny galas and people congratulating themselves for “raising awareness,” these awards are for the other people. The ones doing the unglamorous, quietly revolutionary work that actually shifts the ground under our arts
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 8
By Avery Anderson Some artists bloom slowly. Others spend years quietly filling the room with talent until suddenly—one night, one show, one impossible marathon of a performance—the city realizes, oh… she’s a force of nature. This year, that moment belonged to Julia Rifino. If you’ve been
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 9
by Avery Anderson Some leaders shine on stages. Others shine in boardrooms. Terri Lipsey Scott shines in the moments when someone calls and says, “We need you.” Today’s Orange Blossom Award goes to the Executive Director of the Woodson African American Museum of Florida — a woman whose leadership in
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 10
by Avery Anderson When people talk about “giving artists a voice,” they usually mean the visible parts: the microphone, the camera, the finished clip that pops up in your feed. What they rarely talk about is the person who made sure the microphone worked, the audio didn’t glitch, the
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 11
by Avery Anderson There’s a version of the arts ecosystem that runs on competition, scarcity, and quiet side-eye. And then there’s the version that actually works. This Orange Blossom Award goes to Matthew Morris—because he chose the second one. You might know Matthew as the leader of
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 12
by Avery Anderson Some people leave behind a body of work. Others leave behind a way of working. Stephen Bell was the latter. This year, Tampa Bay lost one of its quiet architects—an artist who didn’t chase the spotlight but somehow illuminated every room he entered. Stephen passed
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 13
by Avery Anderson There’s a particular moment in the life of a theatre company that determines everything that comes next. The founder steps away. The safety net disappears. The question becomes painfully simple: Do we play it safe—or do we decide who we are, right now? This year
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 14
by Avery Anderson Every few years, a city rediscovers a conversation it swore it was already having. In 2025, Tampa Bay is once again talking—loudly—about equity, access, and who actually benefits when a region “thrives.” What’s different this time is the growing recognition that visibility alone isn’
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 15
by Avery Anderson There are artists who build careers. And then there are artists who build ecosystems. Katherine Yacko has spent this year doing the second — often quietly, often in rooms where credit isn’t the point, and often while pregnant. She shows up first as a theatregoer. Not occasionally.
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 16
by Avery Anderson Arts administrators are often praised for keeping the lights on. Darcy Schuller does something more consequential: she builds the conditions that allow ambition to last. Since joining the Museum of Fine Arts, St. Pete in 2021, Schuller—now Deputy Director and COO—has helped guide the institution
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 17
by Avery Anderson There’s a difference between hanging work on a wall and building a space where people feel safe enough to see themselves in it. Freddie Hughes understands that difference—and at The Studio@620, he’s quietly turning it into an ecosystem. Known artistically as FreddieFred, Hughes
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 18
by Avery Anderson This one isn’t for a single person. It’s for the spreadsheet warriors. The midnight submitters. The folks who stared at a score they’d never been punished for before and thought, Wait — what? This year, Florida’s arts funding didn’t just shift. It lurched.
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 19
by Avery Anderson For building new cultural infrastructure—one page at a time Most new arts projects don’t fail because the idea is bad. They fail because the follow-through is brutal. Printing costs. Distribution headaches. Burnout. The slow realization that “launching” is the easy part—and showing up again
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 20
by Avery Anderson Tampa’s music scene doesn’t suffer from a lack of talent. It suffers from fragmentation. Great artists. Scattered rooms. Isolated nights that feel electric inside the venue — and then disappear by morning. What’s rare isn’t the show. It’s the connective tissue that turns
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 21
by Avery Anderson For turning public art into a love letter that will outlast us Some public art is designed to be photographed. The Sunshine City Mosaic was designed to be lived with. Stretching 175 feet through downtown St. Petersburg, the tile installation doesn’t shout for attention. It rewards
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 22
by Avery Anderson For proving collaboration can still be brave In a year when arts organizations were told — implicitly and explicitly — to stay in their lanes, The Good Peaches did the opposite. The production brought together American Stage, The Florida Orchestra, and projectALCHEMY for a genuinely shared act of creation:
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 23
by Avery Anderson Hillsborough County didn’t just lead Florida in book removals this year. It led the country. More than 11,000 physical books were pulled from shelves. Over 500 unique titles were removed at once. And 55 books were permanently taken out of circulation—not after review, but
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 24
by Avery Anderson There are people in the arts community who don’t need to announce their values. You feel them in the way they respond. For Matthew McGee, that response is almost always the same: yes. Before The Arts Passport had a launch plan, a membership structure, or even
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 25
by Avery Anderson Some Orange Blossom Awards go to people with titles. This one goes to the people who made it possible for there to be anything at all. Today—on Christmas Day—we’re honoring Adam and Natalie Bounds, and David DiGioacchino . You won’t see their names on
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 26
by Avery Anderson This Orange Blossom isn’t for a ribbon cutting. It’s for the quiet, exacting, collective work it took to reopen the Florida Holocaust Museum in a year when memory itself feels under threat. Behind the polished cases and calibrated lighting was a staff doing something harder
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 27
by Avery Anderson For building the cultural memory of a place. This December, Orange Blossoms are our way of slowing down in a fast news cycle — a daily pause to recognize the people whose work doesn’t always come with a spotlight, but without whom Tampa Bay’s cultural life
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 28
by Avery Anderson This December, Orange Blossoms are our way of slowing down in a fast news cycle — a daily pause to recognize the people whose work doesn’t always come with a spotlight, but without whom Tampa Bay’s cultural life would look very different. Today’s is for someone
Tampa Bay Arts Passport
December 29
by Avery Anderson Some people are visible champions of the arts. Others are the reason the system works at all. Tracy Kennard belongs firmly in the second category—and St. Petersburg is better for it. In her work with the City of St. Petersburg, Tracy operates at the intersection where
Tampa Bay Arts Passport

More theatre.

After the Shift: How American Stage Is Restructuring Season 49 for Sustainability

'Nobody Is on Their Phone': How Beyond the Wings Theater Built a Community Out of Fairy Tale Chaos

Party Over Principle? Not in 1950: Powerstories Theatre Brings Margaret Chase Smith's Historic Takedown to Tampa
Get the arts in your inbox.
Every Friday. Reviews, shows worth seeing, and interviews you won’t read anywhere else. Free.
